Free Speech or Content Control? EU Regulator Prepares Billion-Dollar Fine Against Musk’s X Platform

Free Speech or Content Control? EU Regulator Prepares Billion-Dollar Fine Against Musk’s X Platform

TLDR:

• EU regulators are considering a $1 billion fine against Elon Musk’s X for Digital Services Act violations
• The fine calculation may include revenue from Musk’s other companies like Tesla and SpaceX
• X’s team called the potential fine “an unprecedented act of political censorship”
• The investigation began in 2023 with preliminary findings issued last year
• X faces a second investigation regarding its approach to policing user content

The European Union is preparing to levy a fine that could exceed $1 billion against X, the social media platform owned by Elon Musk.

This penalty stems from alleged violations of the Digital Services Act (DSA), the EU’s landmark law designed to police social media companies and prevent illegal content online.

The investigation into X began in 2023. EU regulators issued preliminary findings in July 2024 that X had violated the DSA by refusing to provide data to outside researchers and failing to establish proper transparency about advertisers.

The DSA, which came into effect in October 2022, allows regulators to impose fines of up to 6% of a company’s global revenue for violations. Reports suggest that in X’s case, regulators might include revenue from other Musk-controlled companies like Tesla and SpaceX in their calculations.

Political Dimensions

The timing of this regulatory action has added complexity to already strained US-EU relations. With Musk serving as a close adviser to President Donald Trump, the fine could further heighten tensions amid ongoing disputes over trade, tariffs, and other international matters.

EU officials have reportedly been weighing the size of the fine while considering the political implications. However, they maintain that the investigation is proceeding independently from other diplomatic issues.

The regulation of X has become a flashpoint in trans-Atlantic debates about free speech. In February, Vice President JD Vance described the EU’s regulatory approach as “digital censorship.”

X’s Response

In a statement, X’s Global Government Affairs team strongly contested the potential penalty. “If the reports about the EU’s plans are accurate, it represents an unprecedented act of political censorship and an attack on free speech,” the team declared.

The statement added that X has “gone above and beyond to comply with the EU’s Digital Services Act.” The company pledged to “use every option at our disposal to defend our business, keep our users safe, and protect freedom of speech in Europe.”

Legal Battle Ahead

Musk has indicated he intends to fight any penalties. After the preliminary findings were released last July, he stated he was looking forward to “a very public battle in court so that the people of Europe can know the truth.”

Former EU commissioner Thierry Breton disputed Musk’s claim of being offered a secret deal to avoid fines by suppressing certain content. Breton stated that any discussions were in line with “established regulatory procedures.”

Beyond Fines

In addition to the monetary penalty, EU regulators may demand product changes at X. The full scope of the penalties is expected to be announced in the coming months.

There remains a possibility that X and EU regulators could reach a settlement if the platform agrees to policy changes that address regulators’ concerns.

X also faces a second, broader investigation related to its approach to policing user-generated content. Regulators allege this approach has made X “a hub of illegal hate speech and disinformation,” which could result in additional penalties.

The outcome of this case is being closely watched as the first major test of the Digital Services Act. It could establish important precedents for how digital platform regulation is enforced throughout the European Union and potentially influence similar regulatory efforts worldwide.

While EU regulators move forward with their plans, the dispute highlights fundamental differences in approaches to content moderation and free speech between European and American perspectives in the digital age.

When contacted by The New York Times, a spokesman for the European Commission declined to comment specifically on the X case but did affirm that the EU would “continue to enforce our laws fairly and without discrimination toward all companies operating in the EU.”

What happens next remains uncertain, but the case could become a defining moment in the evolving relationship between tech platforms, free speech principles, and government regulation in the digital sphere.

The post Free Speech or Content Control? EU Regulator Prepares Billion-Dollar Fine Against Musk’s X Platform appeared first on CoinCentral.